the film review and why you make the film review 1
Rhetoric-in-Practice Project – general Writing 39B prompt
This project shifts the rhetorical situation from analyzing a message from the position of an audience member (trying to build a deep understanding of the meaning of the text, the context in which the sender created it, and the audiences to which it speaks) to one in which you yourself are a creator, producing a text that is relevant to the class theme or texts.
This project imitates what youâ€™ll be asked to do often in both your college career and afterwardsâ€”discern what you want to say, who you want to say it to, and how best to do so. The Rhetoric-in-Practice assignment is intended to give you a deeper appreciation of what it means to make specific rhetorical choices to serve your message and an opportunity to reflect on how those choices affect the message you are sending and the audience that you reach with it.
In this way, the RIP is a culmination of the work youâ€™ve done in this class with respect to your understanding of both genre and rhetoric.
- Develop clear cogent analyses and convincing arguments about rhetorical choices.
- Identify and articulate genre expectations, situating the text at hand within a larger conversation in a particular rhetorical situation, with a particular audience.
- Select credible and pertinent material from readings and outside texts to support a point or argument, and illustrate awareness of viewpoints and competing arguments.
- Situate, integrate, and contextualize different types of evidence effectively while distinguishing the writerâ€™s voice from those of sources.
- Demonstrate effective organization and style â€“ for a particular purpose, within a particular genre, to a particular audience.
- Connect rhetorical choices from class readings to your own project, applying these principles to your own purposes effectively and appropriately.
- Rewrite and edit language, style, tone, and sentence structure according to genre and audience expectations.
- Practice applying citation conventions systematically in your own work.
- Plan and execute a revision process that does not rely only on direction from the instructor, developing ownership of both process and product to revise purposefully.
The RIP assignment has two parts: project and essay.
Project: You will craft a text having selected a purpose and audience that addresses the class theme (or responds to one of the class texts). You will then select an appropriate genre for this project, and demonstrate your rhetorical know-how by selecting appropriate rhetorical choices for this situation. In other words, your created text will operate within a clear rhetorical frameworkâ€”with a clear context, belonging to an identifiable genre, and with a clear purpose and audienceâ€”that addresses the class theme (or responds to one of the class texts). The only limitation on genre is that it is text-based and it cannot be a short story. Discuss with your instructor if he or she has other limitations.
- Message and Purpose: First, whatâ€™s your message going to be? What do you want to portray about either your class text or class theme? Think about this specifically and complexlyâ€”what are the new insights you can bring to the table? What are arguments that you can make?
- Audience: Once you decide your message, whom do you want to target? Why? And what are going to be the expectations of this audience? What might be difficult in addressing them? Think specifically about who they are and what their expectations will be. How will that affect your appeals to them?
- Context: Whatâ€™s the historical and cultural context of this project? Is this taking place right now? Where and when? How does that influence the project? See the AGWR 39B chapter for more details about exploring context.
- Genre: After you think through all of these possibilities, now you can start to decide on a genre for your project. The RIP project should involve a text-based genre, but is only limited by your imagination. Part of this projectâ€™s goal is for you to explore a genre that youâ€™re not familiar with, so you should pick something that can challenge you in terms of making a complex argument in a different format. There can be multi-modal components to the project, but there should be a significant amount of text should be the primary component. Research various genres online for what might be most compelling to youâ€”for instance, perhaps youâ€™re interested in a short video, but instead can write a film treatment or pitch document for it. Consider your past RIP exercises as a starting point for your final genre project.
*The only genre you may NOT write is a short story.
Essay: You will also write a rhetorical analysis of your own work that analyzes the rhetorical choices you made. The essay should build on your work in the RA essay and indicate how youâ€™re applying your rhetorical know-how. Youâ€™ll include secondary sources that demonstrate, among other things, your understanding of your chosen genre and your understanding of the texts/ideas youâ€™ve studied throughout the quarter.
*The companion essay is worth as much as the project itself. Together, the RIP Project and Essay should be comparable in length and substance to the RA (1800+ words).
Because this is a project that may take time, the planning for the RIP project starts with the RIP exercises youâ€™ve been doing since week 1. These exercises should show that youâ€™re engaged with the work of planning all parts of the project (purpose, audience, genre, and context). Your instructor will coach you about projects that do not have a clear purpose or audience, seem to misunderstand the chosen genre or are likely to be too ambitious, but you need to show ownership of your own process and product.
Multiple drafts, peer review and revision are required elements of the assignment. The RIP projectâ€™s length depends on the purpose, audience and genre, but it should be equal to your Rhetorical Analysis in complexity.
- The RIP essay can be multi-modal if necessary and should be between 500-800 words long.
- A minimum of three (3) sources must be cited in the essay, though the working bibliography with annotations may have 10 or more sources that you read in the process.
Fairy Tale RIP: Write your own fairy-tale related text, with your choice of purpose, message, point of view, audience, context, and genre conventions. You may choose to include visual elements, but your project should be predominantly written text.
- A review of a recent fairy tale film, story collection, retelling, musical, etc.
- A newspaper opinion piece addressed to a specific segment of the public (a real-world audience, or a fictional fairy-tale audience), making an argument about some aspect of fairy tales and modern life.
- A fairy tale-themed magazine issue or feature article (on travel, food, beauty, home, other lifestyle topics)
- A museum exhibit on some aspect of fairy tales, including images of visual objects and extensive labels (http://www.museumsassociation.org/museum-practice/text-and-labels (Links to an external site.))
- A film treatment for a fairy tale movie, presenting a detailed outline of the planned plot, characters, and at least four key scenes
- A video game design document or proposal, including a holistic description of the game and its genre; description of gameplay and special features; description of setting, story, and target audience; marketing analysis and risk analysis of developing the game (http://stemchallenge.org/resources/game-design-documents/ (Links to an external site.))
- A proposal for a theme park attraction or a fairy-tale themed community development (http://entertainmentdesigner.com/ (Links to an external site.))
- A psychological or forensic profile of one of our fairy tale characters
- A TED talk-style presentation (https://www.ted.com/talks (Links to an external site.))
- A business proposal, investment prospectus, or brochure
- An advertisement campaign or public service announcement
- A satire
- Other genres or genre mashups? A â€œGuide to the Fairy Tale Apocalypseâ€?
Feel free to choose (almost) any predominantly-written genre you like. If you have trouble generating ideas or figuring out a fairy tale-themed angle, consider the kinds of texts you will create in your future profession.
Look for models of what you want to create yourself. Models are absolutely key to doing well on the RIP project and essay. If you cannot find several credible models you can imitate, then you have not yet found a viable idea for your RIP project.
Difficult Genres to Avoid (for various reasons):
- You MAY NOT write a short story or some other prose fiction. Explore a less-familiar genre.
- Comic books and other elaborately visual projects require a lot of work to generate enough writing to meet the requirements of the assignment. Also consider: can you draw? Or do you have and know how to use Photoshop, Illustrator, etc.?
- Songs or music videos (can you sing? do you know how to edit video?)
- Children’s books are notoriously difficult to pull off well. Children younger than yourself are surprisingly hard to write for; a young audience will require serious research on specific demographics and child psychology, education, cognitive development, etc. in order to succeed.
- Begin with any sources from the RA that you find inspirational for the RIP. Expand your current annotations to include your reasons for using these sources in the RIP.
- Find real-world primary sources that model specific genre conventions and rhetorical effects that you want to recreate in your RIP project. Write annotations explaining the conventions and/or rhetorical elements you plan to imitate and/or find inspiring.
- Research your chosen audience, context, publication or other venue, and other relevant details. Find secondary sources that help you clarify your rhetorical choices and use of genre conventions.
- Include any other critical sources you find inspirational and write annotations explaining their relevance to your project.
Your RIP Working Bibliography, including all additional sources and annotations, should appear in your Works Cited page for each draft of your RIP companion essay. Each annotation should contain the following information, written in your own words:
- Brief description and analysis of the authorâ€™s ethos, credentials and background (Google this info; 1-2 sentences);
- Summary of the authorâ€™s main argument and key supporting evidence OR description of the relevant rhetorical effects;
- Explanation of reasons why youâ€™re inspired to use this particular source;
- Explanation of how you will use this source in/for your RIP project.
- Your RIP should take inspiration from real-world models of your chosen genre, form, audience, and context. Choose what you like, but donâ€™t just invent what you think they are. Do some research and make informed rhetorical choices. Refer to the WR39B chapter in the AGWR for useful information on how to approach this final assignment.
- You are only required to formally submit two drafts of your RIP project and essay, but you should plan to write many more drafts than that. Hang on to each draft and consider discussing them in your companion essay and your ePortfolio Introduction.